Whiskey Jack wrote:
Probably not, as the only reason you given me to believe that it is unachievable is because it is difficult. From my standpoint, precision instruments are often difficult to design and implement. I don't see why a watch would be any different.
I have no idea whether it's achievable or not, purely in technical terms. As a layperson, I'd accept the argument that it would be difficult, but not necessarily impossible. More realistically, though, I don't see a +/- 1 second/year quartz wristwatch coming about, as there really is no practical need for one. Radio-controlled atomic wristwatches already exist, so right now you can buy a watch that, in its way, is as accurate as the most accurate time-keeping devices on the planet. It's doubtful a quartz movement could ever beat that, so at best it would be playing catch-up. I understand the difference is the quartz movement would be keeping its own time, rather than being reliant on a signal to set itself, but the market segment that would need a watch accurate to within 1 second per year that is
also not signal dependent has to be miniscule. I'm sure the techno-geek faction would appreciate it, but I don't know that they would constitute a viable market, such that we'll see such a movement come about.
I concede that the demand is probably minuscule; unfortunately, I happen to be in that market segment. So you can imagine my frustration searching for a watch that doesn't exist.
That radio signal is nonexistent in remote parts of the world. I usually get the time from GPS, and I'd rather not have to depend on it because if I wanted to use GPS for navigation I wouldn't need an accurate timepiece. For my practical needs 10-20 seconds a year is probably good enough, but knowing GMT to the second after being out a month or two is certainly useful to me. And so, when thinking about the "Perfect Watch" I picked a value accurate enough that further improvement would be meaningless to me. I agree completely that the vast majority of people would have no use for a watch like that, and I wouldn't either if my hobby didn't involve astronomy and celestial navigation.