Thanks so much everyone, I really appreciate it.
I plan on checking out the steelfish and superocean this weekend!
The only problem is measuring his wrist? He is 6'1 I dont know if that will help me guess his wrist size. I actually thought that what you all meant by size was how big the face of the watch would be lol (newbie mistake). I guess going bigger is better and he can always have it sized right?
Also, how do you all feel about getting the watch engraved? Is that defiling the watch? I don't want to ruin it, but I am a chick, we like to personalize stuff. I dont want to write a sonnet or anything on it, maybe just his date of birth and then "Love, N" or something.
If thats a bad idea im ok with it just want to know what you all think.
Thanks again for everyone's input, I really appreciate it.

Natalia